Radical Democracy debate heats up among young scholars in the South

-
By Gerry F. Arambala
Chairperson, Philosophy Department
La Salle University, Ozamiz City


Discussions on President Rodrigo Duterte's radical politics are heating up among young scholars in the South. The works of Patricio Abinales, Heidi K. Gloria, and Reynaldo Ileto provide the historical context. Dr. Christopher Ryan Maboloc, who is recognized by Dr. Julio Teehankee as the first to use Chantal Mouffe's agonistic politics in interpreting the rise to power of President Duterte, is cited by the likes of Wataru Kusaka, Karl Gaspar, and Fr. Jose Mario Francisco, SJ. Dr. Maboloc, who teaches philosophy at Ateneo de Davao University, argues that the contested nature of politics in the country can be traced to the unjust structures of post-colonial Philippine society. 

In a recent talk, Prof. Menelito Mansueto of Letran suggested that non-dominant narratives have been silenced after EDSA. In an online article, UP Cebu Prof. Regletto Imbong wrote a critical but fair comment on Maboloc's work, claiming that he (Maboloc) missed the fact that exclusion is not exclusive to Mindanao but is experienced by all poor people in the country. Meanwhile, Fr. Raymun Festin, SVD analyzed Maboloc's radical democracy hypothesis with regard to Duterte's role in Philippine politics. Dr. Maboloc has published several papers on the topic, his position anchored mainly in the failures of the country's liberal institutions due to the elitist nature of Philippine democracy.

Dean Benjie Labastin's work contrasting radical politics and Dutertismo ramains pivotal in all the debates. Maboloc's presentation of his paper in a UST conference elicited various reactions and tough questions, but the scholar was firm on his stand. In the end, Maboloc's work can be credited for introducing the agonistic theory of democracy in explaining Duterte's unconventional approach. In a paper that will be released as a chapter in a book to be published in the US, I have discussed the important role played by our local scholars in understanding the politics of our time. I will present the nature of politics in Ozamiz, which can be considered as contested.

Popular posts from this blog

Gazing into the Abyss of Political Decay

-
Image
By Prof. Menelito Mansueto (MSU-IIT)  There's a circus in town but we need to know who the real clowns are. The desecration of the Kingdom of Jesus Christ is a manifestation of the way power politics operates in this country. The recent attacks on VP Sara Duterte is not very different from the old style of character assassinations. But it is KOJC Pastor Apollo Quiboloy who has become the proxy in the war between the House of Marcos and the House of Duterte. Now is the season of politics.  The storyline goes to show that once again Philippine democracy is the loser. Instead of spending on infrastructure such as the Mindanao railway or the Cebu - Bohol Bridge, billions of funds in the form of ayuda are used for politicking. We are wasting public resources on bad political habits and practices. The government is functioning like an organized crime syndicate where stealing public money has become rampant. But the story extends further.  What is appalling is that those who que...
Read more

What does it mean to be a Scholar?

-
Image
  By Menelito Mansueto, MA MSU-IIT  One of the heated issues in academia today is the ranking of scholars based on citations. It's only in the Philippines that getting cited is a source of scorn for some. So, let's look at the facts. Being cited means that other scholars are reading your work. It doesn't mean though that your paper has no value if it's not cited. A paper has several academic purposes. In the area of scholarship, however, if one claims to be an expert on a topic or a philosopher, it's important to consider the impact of your work among your peers, here and abroad. Internationally, top scholars have thousands of citations, which makes them influential in the field. In the Philippines, especially for Philosophy, it's quite an achievement to be recognized by your peers. We can mention two names, Jeremiah Joaquin and FPA Demeterio, both from DLSU. JJ has 594 citations while Demeterio has 395 citations. JJ's work is on analytic philosophy while De...
Read more

Filipino Philosophy or A Filipino's Philosophy: Clarificatory Notes

-
Image
By Dr. Noel S. Pariñas Yes, the title is an exclusive disjunction, but it can be reformulated as a conjunctive statement as well. Obviously, the first disjunct is different from the second disjunct. Since the disjunctive statement is not tautological, the alternatives cannot replace each other. When the disjuncts are used synonymously and interchangeably, a philosophical problem would necessarily arise. Such a philosophical problem will give birth to debates and conflicting views without a definite path towards the possibility of resolution except when the context is made clear. There are philosophies in the Philippines; there are Filipinos doing philosophy; there are Filipino philosophers; there are Filipino philosophical writings; and every Filipino embraces an existentially personal philosophy. All these things mentioned are not materially equivalent to Filipino philosophy. Neither the above-mentioned can be logical grounds to justify the existence of the so-called Filipino philosop...
Read more